<p>Yes, you can! I tried it on 5 horses and always got the same message in the image below. <img below.</p><p>"The horse happily munches the sugar oat and runs on. You shouldn't steal one of the horse station's horses anyway."</p><p>It does take one of your sugar oats each try. </p><p><img alt="" src="https://www.tibiaqa.com/?qa=blob&qa_blobid=6451741642735564858" style="height:527px; width:600px"></p>