Hello Shawtay!
I tried my self and the max creatures you can add to your bestiary tracker are 50 entries. This also is the same limit for both premium and free accounts. After that you will not have the option available to add more creatures, as the picture below shows:
Question Revival V contestMarch 17, 2024
Interview with Solkrin - lead of the Customer Support team at CipSoftDecember 20, 2023
Become a TibiaQA Supporter!May 09, 2023