Yes, the color of the box affects the items. Below is a list of boxes that can be pulled from The Ambrosia Buffet.
Box Full of Presents
Carpet Box Carpet Box
Special Balloon Box
Special Carpet Box
Special Fx Box
Also you can get Dragon Pinata Kit.
Source : TibiaFandom
Introducing the ability to bump and pin questionsJanuary 09, 2022
Fourth Anniversary InfographicDecember 30, 2021
Interview with Laethye - Game Content Designer of TibiaNovember 23, 2021